Holland on Paper in the Age of Art Nouveau is a handsomely produced volume that makes an important contribution to current English-language scholarship concerning Dutch works on paper from the 1890s and early years of the 20th century. The book brings together a selection of prints and drawings from the Boston Museum of Fine Arts collection of turn-of-the-century Dutch drawings and prints. Written by Clifford S. Ackley, the man who for more than three decades has been in charge of collecting, caring for and curating the works, with research assistant Katherine Harper, Holland on Paper provides a strong, visually rich entry point to the subject.
Ackley, whose book Printmaking in the Age of Rembrandt1 and other publications on Dutch art of the 17th century have long established him as an expert in the field, here turns his attention to Art Nouveau—De Nieuwe Kunst, in Dutch—and the period sometimes known as Holland’s “second golden age.” As Ackley discusses in his introductory essay, his own fascination with the period originated in his years studying in the Netherlands in the late 1950s and ’60s, but was pursued in earnest beginning in the 1980s when he became head of the print department in Boston. He inherited a small but stellar collection that included an early Mondrian charcoal landscape from ca. 1905–7 (Fig. 1) and a van Gogh etching from 1890 of Dr. Gachet (Fig. 2). This formed the nucleus of what has become an outstanding North American collection of Dutch works on paper from this period—indeed one of the strongest outside Holland. As Ackley observes:
These works … may not form as perfect a survey as might be drawn from the collections of the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam …, the Gemeentemuseum in The Hague, or the Museum Boijmans van Beuningen in Rotterdam, but they do introduce the visual preoccupations and imagery that are central to this highly creative and still relatively unknown period of Dutch art.2
The unusually diverse geographic variation of Art Nouveau has recently been the focus of a slow but steady reconsideration as new scholarship emerges and existing studies are translated into English or other widely read languages. Scholars are increasingly turning their attention to art historical developments outside the dominant narratives that position Paris at the epicenter of the modern art world. Holland on Paper adds to this larger revisionist project, enriching and enlivening our understandings of the period.
Ackley begins by outlining major cultural shifts in Holland in the final decades of 19th century that have seldom been discussed outside Dutch-language publications. Beginning with the 1880s art-for-art’s sake aesthetic associated with the periodical De Nieuwe Gids and followed in the 1890s by a more socially oriented concern for an engaged art related to the concept of Gemeenschaps-kunst (Community Art), Ackley outlines the developments of this period in broad strokes. He points to the wealth of styles—various strands of Realism and Symbolism co-existing with early abstract tendencies—and to the equally abundant array of ideological underpinnings ranging from sociopolitical (socialist, anarchist) and religious (Theosophical, Rosicrucian) to the scientific (natural history, botany).
The heart of the book is the “selective pictorial survey” of 117 exquisite plates of individual prints and drawings by more than 30 artists. Each is discussed briefly and illustrated with at least one high-quality reproduction, often augmented by a close-up detail or reproductions of additional art works as visual comparisons. The format facilitates a full understanding of variations of technique and exposes the Dutch preoccupation with fine draftsmanship as well as the often virtuosic graphic achievement attained during this period of print discovery and innovation. It is in this section that one finds the true strength of this publication—a visual compendium that is astonishing to the newcomer and affirming of the period’s variety and depth to the initiate.
Of the artists included, Jan Toorop and the lesser-known but highly noteworthy graphic designer Theo van Hoytema, are by far the best represented, with more than 20 works by each. Toorop is usually the dominant figure in surveys of the period, and he emerges as the protagonist of Dutch Art Nouveau as it is presented in this book. His widely reproduced poster Delft Salad Oil (Fig. 3), which appears as a detail on the cover, serves as an entry point to the book as a whole and to the introductory essay. The stylized, sinuous lines of Toorop’s poster tie the Java-born Dutchman to international experiments in graphic design and the decorative arts, especially those of Brussels. The poster is a reminder of the transnational complexities of the period, and its status as an advertisement underlines the period’s desire to improve the aesthetic quality of all that is designed, imparting beauty and dignity to the objects of everyday life.
Van Hoytema was a particularly popular artist in turn-of-the-century Holland, due in large part to his calendars and children’s picture books, but he has not enjoyed the same level of historical recognition as Toorop, making his inclusion in Holland on Paper all the more welcome. Van Hoytema’s early years included a formative period as an artist in the Leiden Zoological Museum (1889–1990), and his precise observation of the natural world led to works characterized by botanical and zoological accuracy on the one hand and pattern and composition on the other. The latter aligned him with wider Art Nouveau stylistic concerns. His best works, such as the lithograph Christmas Eve (Fig. 4), reveal a fine balance between detailed renderings of the natural world and abstracted and decorative framing. His formal experimentation with texture results in a densely articulated surface, and a visually distinct aspect of van Hoytema’s lithography that warrants underlining.
At the other end of the stylistic spectrum from Toorop, and indicative of the period’s diversity within Holland, is the sparer geometric abstraction evident in furniture design that also found its way into graphic production. Of particular note is Johan Thorn Prikker’s design for the Dutch art exhibition at the Kaiser Wilhelm Museum in Krefeld, Germany (Fig. 5). Best known for his mystical symbolist paintings of the 1890s, Prikker here combines abstract design components with roots in the natural world, a nod toward batik design, bold typography and geometric framing. His subsequent design experiments tied him to Belgium (especially to the architect and designer Henry van de Velde) and to Germany, which became his home soon after he designed this poster.
Other highlights include the posters of the committed socialist Richard Roland Holst, the book design of Gerrit Willem Dijsselhof, the botanical studies of Theo Nieuwenhuis, the mystical, theosophically informed woodcuts of K. P. C. De Bazel and the exotic, intricate draftsmanship and decorative surface ornamentation of C. A. Lion Cachet.
Completing this beautiful and useful addition to existing literature are a glossary of printmaking techniques, a short essay on Dutch printmaking and printmakers from the period, and an excellent bibliography. It is relevant to both the matter of the book and to Art in Print to note that the book design by Susan Marsh is both aesthetically pleasing and fitting to the subject. (One minor quibble is the omission of clear labeling to identify the fine yet nonsequentially placed details of the images, leaving it to the intrigued reader to leaf through the book attempting to match the detail to a full-size image elsewhere, or to discover the list of details located inconspicuously on the final page with the colophon information.)
Ackley concludes his introductory remarks: “I trust that my own subjective observations about these works convey some of my sense of visual discovery.” This is exactly what this book achieves. Ackley has, in this stunning volume, contributed significantly to the larger project of opening up to the English-speaking world an intriguing chapter in what has until recently been among the best kept secrets of modern art. With the appearance of this splendidly illustrated and valuable book, the secret is out.
- Boston Museum of Fine Arts, 1981.
- Holland on Paper, 9.